The importance of Daily Defect reports for HGV&PSV
Strengthening Driver Defect Reporting: Operator Responsibilities and Best Practices
One of the key duties of a responsible operator is ensuring that vehicle defect reporting is properly managed, monitored, and enforced. Despite its importance, this area remains one of the most common failings identified by the DVSA and Traffic Commissioners during investigations and public inquiries.
To maintain compliance and uphold road safety standards, operators should be actively overseeing the driver defect reporting system through the following best practices:
Key Operator Responsibilities:
Complete and Accurate Reporting: Ensure all driver defect reports are fully completed — whether defects are found or not. ‘Nil defect’ reports are just as important and should be submitted without exception.
Clear Audit Trails: When a defect is reported, there must be a documented audit trail showing the issue, the action taken, and final sign-off. This closes the loop and demonstrates effective oversight.
Random Vehicle Spot Checks: Conduct unannounced spot checks after drivers complete their walkaround inspections but before the vehicle departs. These checks should be recorded and stored with the vehicle’s maintenance history. A simple system will suffice, as long as it's consistent and documented.
PMI Sheet Review: Scrutinise service inspection sheets following Preventative Maintenance Inspections (PMIs). Look for any defects that should have been identified during a daily check. If faults are found, cross-reference with previous driver defect reports to evaluate driver performance and reporting accuracy.
Monitoring Common Issues: Track recurring defects, such as faulty bulbs or tyre issues (e.g. low tread or damage). Persistent problems may indicate that checks are being rushed or not carried out at all. Minor but telling issues — like cracked mirrors or damaged steps — can also reflect driver diligence levels.
Clear Procedures and Training: Maintain written daily walkaround check procedures and ensure all drivers are thoroughly trained. Keep detailed records of training sessions, including trainer names, content delivered, and signed attendance sheets.
Active Follow-Up and Enforcement: Speak directly with drivers when issues arise. Start with re-training, but escalate to disciplinary action where necessary. Repeat non-compliance must be addressed promptly and seriously.
‘Check the Checkers’: Transport managers and supervisory staff must themselves be regularly reviewed to ensure they are policing defect reporting properly and not allowing standards to slip.
---
Why This Matters: The Link Between Management and Compliance
In many cases, failures in driver defect reporting are not simply the result of driver negligence — they stem from weak or inconsistent management practices. The most effective operators embed defect reporting into their company culture through the following three pillars:
1. Simplicity and Clarity: Have a clearly defined, easy-to-follow defect reporting system in place. Simplicity ensures understanding and compliance.
2. Training and Communication: Provide ongoing training for all relevant staff. Ensure drivers understand why the system matters and how to follow it correctly.
3. Ongoing Monitoring and Action: Regularly review, audit, and take corrective action where needed. Non-compliance must be met with retraining or disciplinary steps — not indifference.
---
Final Thoughts
While it may feel repetitive to revisit the topic of defect reporting, it remains one of the most common and serious causes of regulatory intervention. Operators who overlook this area — or fail to manage it robustly — risk enforcement action, reputational damage, and even the loss of their operator licence.
The lesson is clear: don’t just trust the process — actively manage it.
